Search

Related Music Theory Alchemy

“Penny Lane,” written by the Beatles, utilizes key changes and borrowed chords to create an interesting and complex tonal palette. The song is best understood to primarily be in the key of A Major; however, it frequently borrows chords from the parallel minor key, uses unexpected dominant chords, and briefly modulates to other key areas for color and variety. This is characteristic of several Beatles songs, and it’s one of the ways they added complexity to their music while still remaining accessible.

“In My Life” is a song written by The Beatles which stands as a hallmarks of their inventive songwriting and command of complex musical structures. The song is primarily in the key of A Major, but it employs a number of borrowed chords and modal interchange to create a more interesting and richer harmonic landscape. The melody, rhythm, and lyrics of this song are poignant and memorable, making “In My Life” an enduring classic in the Beatles’ catalog.

“Give Me The Night” by George Benson features a smooth jazz and funk-influenced style. The chord progression in Verse 3 demonstrates a strong use of extended and altered chords, which create a richer texture and interesting harmonic movement. This particular chord progression is reminiscent of other popular songs from the same period and genre, displaying the influence of jazz harmony on contemporary R&B and pop music.

This is simply a repetition of the F major chord, played four times. This does not provide much variety or harmonic interest, but it might create a sense of stability and could be used to produce a strong tonal center.

“Boulevard of Broken Dreams” by Green Day is set in the key of E minor, and uses a recurrent sequence of four chords throughout the song: Em, G, D, and A. The prevalence of this progression endows the song with an air of melancholy, aligning with its lyrical themes of loneliness and disillusionment. These four chords create a harmonic loop that reflects the circulative narrative portrayed in the lyrics.

The Beatles – Penny Lane – Verse 3

Add To Favorites Remove From Favorites

< All Analyses

Chord Progression

[‘A’, ‘F#m’, ‘Bm’, ‘E7’, ‘A’, ‘F#m’, ‘Am’, ‘F’, ‘E7’]

Chord Progression Analysis

“`
Verse 3:
A Major (I)
F# minor (vi)
B minor (ii)
E7 (V7)
A Major (I)
F# minor (vi)
A minor (borrowed iv chord from parallel minor)
F Major (borrowed flat VI chord from parallel minor)
E7 (V7)
“`

The progression starts with the I-vi-ii-V7, a common cadence in pop music. Following this, it repeats the I-vi before introducing the A minor and the F major chords, borrowed from A minor, which is the parallel minor of A Major. E7 then acts as the dominant, leading to next key area.

Similar Chord Progressions

There are countless songs throughout pop history that use similar songwriting devices, however, few songs use these techniques with the finesse of The Beatles. For example:

– “Creep” by Radiohead also uses the borrowed flat Major chord from the parallel minor key.
“`
Chord progression:
G Major (I)
B Major (Borrowed III from parallel minor)
C Major (IV)
C minor (iv)
“`

– “Hotel California” by The Eagles uses borrowed chords, it progresses from a major key to a minor key.
“`
Chord progression:
B minor (i)
F# (V)
A Major (VII)
E Major (IV)
G Major (VI)
D Major (III)
Em (v)
F# (V)
“`

– “God Only Knows” by The Beach Boys, being a baroque pop, utilizes similar key changes and complex chord progressions.
“`
Chord progression:
A Major (I)
Bm (ii)
C#m (iii)
D Major (IV)
Dm (iv)
A Major (I)
“`

Musical Analysis

The Beatles apply advanced songwriting techniques. Interestingly, they move from the relative minor (F# minor) to the minor iv (Am) – a borrowed chord from the parallel minor (A minor) which infuses a little bit of melancholy into the melody. This is then followed by an F Major chord, another borrowed chord which provides a jazzy and bluesy touch to the song.

Overall Analysis

“Penny Lane” by The Beatles is an eclectic and elegant piece of music evident in its rhythm, harmony, melody, and lyrics. It is predominantly in the key of A Major, but it has several key changes and introduces chords that are non-diatonic, giving it a progressive and unexpected feel.

Style Analysis

“Penny Lane” reflects the pop, rock, and baroque-pop style of The Beatles. The lush melody, counterpoint-like writing, and secondary dominant chords reflect baroque music and early music influence. The use of borrowed chords also reflects the broader influence of jazz and blues on The Beatles.

Chords in the Verse 3 section of Penny Lane by The Beatles are:

[‘A’, ‘F#m’, ‘Bm’, ‘E7’, ‘A’, ‘F#m’, ‘Am’, ‘F’, ‘E7’]